Archive for December, 2009

Coal news roundup, Holiday Edition

Wednesday, December 30, 2009

chinadec2009.jpg

Rescuers gather at the entrance of a shaft of Malishu Coal Mine in Shuangbai County, Chuxiong Yi Autonomous Prefecture, southwest China’s Yunnan Province, Dec. 28, 2009. Five miners are dead and six are missing after a gas burst at the Malishu Coal Mine early Monday, local authorities said. (Xinhua/Chen Haining)

Back-to-back coal mining explosions in China this week have killed at least 18 miners, and the death count may rise because of other workers who are missing.

At least 12 workers died in a gas explosion Sunday at the Donggou Colliery in Jiexiu City, Shanxi province in Northern China. And early Monday, another explosion killed at least six in southwest China’s Yunnan Province.

Closer to home, the great Louisville Courier-Journal reporter Ralph Dunlop profiled miner and mine safety crusader Scott Howard in this piece. He quotes Howard:

My ancestors fought for better safety, and I’m not gonna go back. I’m not dependent on that company. I’m dependent on God. And God don’t put us here to be trampled on, mistreated.

(more…)

MSHA marks annivesary of 1969 mine safety law

Wednesday, December 30, 2009

farmington-photo.jpg

Longtime Charleston Gazette photographer Larry Pierce took this famous photo of the Farmington Disaster, which was a defining event that pushed Congress to write a new mine safety and health law.

This statement just in from the U.S. Mine Safety and Health Administration:

WASHINGTON – The U.S. Department of Labor’s Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA) today commemorated the 40th anniversary of the signing of the Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act of 1969 (Mine Act), which instituted the strongest and most comprehensive occupational safety and health protections that had ever been enacted in the country.

The Mine Act was born out of a mining disaster that occurred in November 1968, when 78 miners died in an explosion at Consolidation Coal’s No. 9 mine in Farmington, W.Va. Members of the mining community, angered by the continuing toll being taken on the lives of miners, rallied together and called for sweeping changes. Widows of some of the fallen miners even traveled to Washington to testify before Congress.

(more…)

Coal and climate change: The industry’s fuzzy math

Wednesday, December 30, 2009

yescoal-300x240.jpg

Do all of West Virginia’s trees take in enough carbon dioxide to make the state carbon neutral?

Well, that’s the line that coal industry has been pushing, and that some lawmakers are apparently buying. But whatever math they’ve got to back this up is pretty fuzzy, according to independent scientists I asked to check into the issue for Coal Tattoo. In fact, the industry is off by about a factor of 15 … read on and I’ll explain how that is.

Frankly, I had hoped this issue would go away. A friend among the statehouse press corps pointed it out to me during last year’s session, after at least one lawmaker spouted off about West Virginia’s ample forest cover making the state “carbon neutral.”

(more…)

What are the year’s biggest coal stories?

Tuesday, December 29, 2009

germanpower-plant.jpg

Steam and smoke is seen over the coal burning power plant in Gelsenkirchen, Germany, on Wednesday, Dec. 16, 2009. Coal power plants are among the biggest producer of CO2, that is believed to be responsible for climate change. Delegates from 193 nations at a U.N. climate talks conference in Copenhagen are deadlocked in talks on a deal to curb global warming. (AP Photo/Martin Meissner)

It’s been an interesting year — to say the least — here in the Appalachian coalfields.

So what do Coal Tattoo readers think are the biggest coal-related stories of 2009? Please join in with your comments, and provide links to articles that illustrate your point. To get things started, here are some ideas, offered in no particular order — and without defining what is meant by the “biggest” story … I’ll leave that to you to decide. Here we go:

waxmanmarkey.jpg

The U.S. House and a Senate committee moved forward with strong legislation to try to deal with global warming. Despite the United Mine Workers union’s statement that the House bill would ensure the future of coal, many industry officials continue to oppose congressional action. Some factions in the coal industry, led by Massey’s Don Blankenship, try to convince coalfield residents there’s no such thing as global warming and sponsor rallies against any action on the issue.

obamaregionalreporters.jpg

The Obama administration announced plans for a crackdown on mountaintop removal, saying various agencies would be taking unprecedented steps to reduce the impacts of this form of mining.

coaldrag.JPG

A variety of factors – the economic downturn, declining reserves, and concerns about global warming — are major setbacks for the coal industry, especially in Central Appalachia.  More and more, analysts are talking about the region soon reaching “Peak Coal” and then seeing production and jobs steadily decline. No new coal-fired power plants were started in 2009.

3639737861_6e058db1f4.jpg

Coalfield residents and activists from around the country carried out a series of peaceful civil disobedience protests  aimed at shutting down mountaintop removal operations and pressuring government agencies to ban mountaintop removal.

coalfieldsflashpoint4.jpg

Coal miners, their families and supporters fought back, mounting counter-protests and, according to the latest dispatch by the AP’s Vicki Smith, creating fears that violence would erupt as the mountaintop removal issue continues to heat up.

(more…)

PATH update: Power line seeks to pull Va. application

Tuesday, December 29, 2009

1753204thb.jpg

Some mighty interesting news  just in about the PATH power line … It seems that the power companies have filed papers with the Virginia Corporations Commission indicating that the latest analysis shows the project isn’t needed in 2014, as they have been arguing.

The filing comes in the eve of a big hearing in Virginia, where PATH had already asked that its application be dismissed. But previously, developers said they planned to refile in early 2010, so they could better coordinate petitions in Virginia, Maryland and West Virginia. But now, they’re saying that they aren’t sure when they will refile — but it certainly won’t be before the third quarter of 2010.

Bill Howley has been kind enough to post the new Virginia filing on this Power Line blog, and you can find interesting commentary on it from Bill there as well.

Remember that the West Virginia Public Service Commission already delayed its hearing on the PATH portions in our state until late 2010, and scheduled a final decision to be due by Feb. 24, 2011.

Judge Chambers allows Fola Coal to keep mining

Tuesday, December 29, 2009

Word just in from CONSOL Energy Inc. that will be welcome news for 500 coal miners and their families up in the Clay County area of West Virginia.

U.S. District Judge Robert C. Chambers has granted CONSOL an extension, allowing the company to continue operating at its Ike Fork Mine, despite the lack of public input on a mitigation plan for the company’s Clean Water Act permit.

In a three-page order signed yesterday,  Chambers granted CONSOL subsidiary Fola Coal’s request for the extension, giving the company authority to continue to operate “pending further order of the court.”

Recall that earlier this month, Chambers blocked Fola’s permit after ruling that the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers wrongly denied the public a chance to comment on the mitigation plan, a key part of large surface mining permits.  The ruling prompted CONSOL to announce that it planned to lay off 378 workers at Ike Fork and 104 workers at the related Little Eagle Coal Co. underground mine.

In a news release, CONSOL vice president Nicholas J. DeIuliis said:

We are very pleased by Judge Chambers’ ruling, which is welcome news to our nearly 500 Fola employees and their families, especially during this Holiday Season. This ruling will allow us to re-focus our attention on operating the Fola Complex safely, efficiently and in an environmentally sound manner.

According to court documents, the relief granted by Judge Chambers will allow Fola to continue mining for at least another 12 months.

(more…)

Both sides pressuring OSMRE on buffer zone rule

Tuesday, December 29, 2009

valley_fills.jpgTomorrow is the deadline for public comments to be submitted to the federal Office of Surface Mining Reclamation and Enforcement for the agency’s advance notice of proposed rulemaking on the stream “buffer zone” rule.

Coal industry lobbyists and environmental groups are both encouraging their supporters to contact OSMRE, with quite different messages.

Just before Christmas, Friends of Coal  sent out an “urgent” alert warning its members that, “The federal government is ready to advance another of its attacks on coal mining in West Virginia and across the country.”  The group falsely told its members that OSMRE “has published an Advance Notice of Rulemaking that would restrict the ability to underground or surface mine anywhere in the nation.”

Of course, OSMRE has not proposed anything at this point. As I discussed previously, the agency listed a variety of options for how it might rewrite the buffer zone rule. Some are more stringent than others. But OSMRE has not expressed a preference, and no changes in the current way the buffer zone is enforced appear to be coming anytime soon, given OSMRE’s recent backing of the way the West Virginia Department of Environmental Protection is enforcing its buffer zone rule. And OSMRE isn’t even planning a proposed rule be published in the Federal Register until early in 2011.

(more…)

Remembering the Wilberg Mine Disaster

Monday, December 28, 2009

wilberg.jpg

An MSHA photo shows the monument to the Wilberg miners with the monument’s creator, Gary Prazen.

Hey folks, Coal Tattoo is back up and running … I hope everyone had a good Christmas.

There’s always lots to catch up on, and I wanted first to point out  a commentary by Labor Secretary Hilda Solis remembering the Dec. 19, 1984, Wilberg Mine Disaster in Utah. Among other things, Solis writes:

Twenty-seven lives might have been saved if properly ventilated and effective escape routes had existed. It was a harsh and costly lesson to learn. As with most mining tragedies, however, it also gave way to improvements in mine safety. These included the development of smaller self-contained self-rescuers that can be readily available to miners, keeping tailgate entries open, and preventing roof falls on longwalls to help miners easily escape in the event of an emergency. Specific protections were also added for miners working in Utah’s unique geologic conditions, and each one is an important step forward in safety.

That line about SCSRs seems to be a bit of an exaggeration, given that the Sago and Darby disasters and the Aracoma Mine fire suggested problems  with the number and location of SCSRs — as well as the training of miners to use them — remained long after the rules MSHA put in place following Wilberg. MSHA and various mining states made more changes in the last four years, but Davitt McAteer’s special report on the Sago disaster called for even more reforms to make SCSRs more reliable for miners.

(more…)

Merry Christmas from Coal Tattoo

Friday, December 18, 2009

coal-carolers.jpg

Coal Tattoo is going to be closing down for a week or so for Christmas. We’ll be back online Dec. 28. Hopefully, there won’t be any major news — especially bad news — between now and then.

Historically, this has been a tough time in the coalfields.  Low barometric pressure and low humidity, along with seasonal drying of many areas in underground mines, have contributed to a larger number of mine explosions during winter months.

(more…)

Reports of a climate deal … at least a first step

Friday, December 18, 2009

obamacopenhagen.jpg

U.S. President Barack Obama, fourth from left, is joined by other leaders, including Brazilian President Inacio Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva, third from left, Chinese Prime Minister Wen Jiabao, fifth from right, and Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, fourth from right, in a multilateral meeting at the United Nations Climate Change Conference at the Bella Center in Copenhagen, Denmark Friday, Dec. 18, 2009. (AP Photo/Susan Walsh)

There’s word from various news outlets, including The New York Times, of some sort of a deal in the Copenhagen climate talks:

The United States, China, India and South Africa have reached a “meaningful agreement” at the Copenhagen climate change conference, an Obama administration official said. 

“It’s not sufficient to combat the threat of climate change, but it’s an important first step,” the official said. “No country is entirely satisfied with each element, but this is a meaningful and historic step forward and a foundation from which to make progress.”

“Developed and developing countries have now agreed to listing their national actions and commitments, a finance mechanism, to set a mitigation target of two degrees celsius, and to provide information on the implementation of their actions through national communications, with provisions for international consultations and analysis under clearly defined guidelines,” the official said.

AP is reporting that President Obama will be speaking about this soon, and that the video will be available here.

Please feel free to pass on links to other coverage and commentary.

Friday roundup, Dec. 18, 2009

Friday, December 18, 2009

bangladeshcoal.jpg

Climate refugee Abul Mia, who lost his home to floods, carries coal at a brick field on the outskirts of Dhaka, Bangladesh, Thursday, Dec. 17, 2009. Disagreements between developing and developed countries, especially between China and the United States, which together emit about 40 percent of the world’s heat-trapping greenhouse gases, have hindered progress at the U.N. climate conference, which many say will end without a deal. (AP Photo/ Pavel Rahman)

This was a fascinating photograph, I thought, that includes so many important elements about coal, climate change, and the future of the world.

Of course, Bangladesh is at great risk from rising sea levels caused by global warming.  But it also uses coal, for things like a brick industry and household heating. And, at least according to this report, the country is trying to improve its environmental performance in these areas.

As I write this, we still don’t know for sure what’s going to come out of the Copenhagen climate talks. I’m sure we’ll be talking about that for some time, though. So much of what’s going on there is about the understandable desire of other nations and other people to develop.  And smart people are trying to ensure that we rich countries at least try to help the developing world avoid the mistakes we’ve made along the way.

It’s interesting, then, that carbon capture and storage for coal gets shut out of the picture, as reported previously on Coal Tattoo and now in a follow-up Wall Street Journal blog post. As Gene Trisko of the United Mine Workers told me in an e-mail message this week:

CCS is not included on the list of technologies that can qualify for CDM projects under Kyoto (neither is nuclear).  This means that a US firm investing in CCS in China cannot earn CDM credits for the CO2 reduced.

West Virginia Congresswoman Shelley Moore Capito, a Republican, blogged about this in a dispatch from Copenhagen:

Carbon capture is our most important tool to address carbon dioxide emissions from coal.  It will not only benefit a state like mine with jobs and revenue, it will also benefit our nation and world by making clean coal a reality. 

It’s irresponsible that negotiators in Copenhagen seem to have brushed it aside.

A Coal Tattoo reader pointed out this interesting piece in the Toronto Globe and Mail, focusing on reactions to Copenhagen and climate change legislation in the heart of U.S. coal country, Greene County, Pa.  Here’s how it starts out:

Almost anywhere you plant your feet in fatefully named Greene County, Pa., you are likely to be standing on a bed of coal, the condemnable, combustible rock whose future is now being framed 6,500 kilometres away at a global climate-change summit in Copenhagen.

On some patches of this quiet stretch of the Allegheny Plateau all that remains below are the pillars of coal left standing to prevent the ground above from collapsing when the area was mined starting a century ago to feed Andrew Carnegie’s steel mills 100 kilometres north in Pittsburgh.

(more…)

Big coal worried about ‘Appalachian Restoration Act’

Friday, December 18, 2009

mtr_gao.JPG

Coal industry lobbyists must be pretty worried about the possibilities for passage by Congress of the Appalachian Restoration Act. The National Mining Association yesterday sent out an alert asking its members and supporters to contact lawmakers and voice opposition to the bill:

The Senate Environment and Public Works Committee could soon vote on legislation introduced by Sens. Ben Cardin (D-Md.) and Lamar Alexander (R-Tenn.) that could eliminate or severely restrict all types of coal mining.

ACT now and contact your Senators and urge them to oppose the so-called “Appalachian Restoration Act” (S. 696).

This bill jeopardizes the future of domestic coal mining and will saddle American consumers and businesses with massive energy price hikes.  Hundreds of thousands of mining jobs could be lost and many projects intended to stimulate the economy will never be brought to fruition.

ACT now and urge Congress to reject misguided and ill-informed efforts to prohibit mining practices that create good American jobs and help power our homes and businesses with abundant and affordable domestic energy.

(more…)

Industry pressuring Obama on coal-ash rules

Friday, December 18, 2009

coal-sludge-image.jpg

There’s an interesting report out today from the Center for Progressive Reform’s CPR Blog, following up on yesterday’s EPA announcement of a delay in issuing a rules proposal on toxic coal-ash handling and disposal.

(See my previous breaking new blog post and a Gazette print story here and here).

It seems that in the months leading up to EPA’s decision to delay its rules proposal, officials from various affected industries met with the White House Office of Management and Budget 10 times to discuss the topic. It’s worth nothing that this list of meetings only runs up through Nov. 17 — we don’t know what meetings took place after that.

As James Goodwin explained:

Based on the meeting records on OIRA’s website, no other specific regulatory issue has attracted this much industry attention. (EPA’s controversial rule on greenhouse gas reporting, in comparison, only generated six meetings between industry representatives and OIRA.) The peak came on Thursday, November 12, when OIRA hosted three different meetings with industry officials to discuss coal ash disposal. Industry reps must have lined up outside the EEOB like teenagers waiting for the opening day showing of New Moon.

(more…)

Friends of Coal gears up to protect school program

Friday, December 18, 2009

foc_logo_download.jpgFriends of Coal is urging its supporters to get involved in defending an industry “education” program that’s being used in Raleigh County schools … here’s the group’s latest e-mail alert:

Radicals try to silence Ladies Auxiliary’s “Coal in the Classroom” Series Please contact the Beckley Register-Herald and show your support for coal (Read the story below) or go to this link:  http://www.register-herald.com/archivesearch/local_story_349224151.html

(more…)

Coal states oppose increased OSMRE oversight

Thursday, December 17, 2009

42_tn.jpg

Coal-mining states and their regulatory agencies are starting a fight against efforts by the Obama administration to increase its oversight of how those states police strip-mining.

Last week, the Interstate Mining Compact Commission issued a letter blasting the OSMRE plan, saying it would “seriously encroach upon and likely erode” the rights of states to regulate strip-mining within their borders under the 1977 strip mining law.

I’ve posted a copy of the letter here, and OSMRE has more information on its proposals here. Interestingly, OSMRE just announced on Tuesday — not long after the commission letter — that it would extend the public comment period on its proposals for increased oversight of state regulatory programs.

pizarchik.JPGThis will be a big test for OSMRE Director Joe Pizarchik — will he stand up to the states and continue this increased oversight plan? Remember that citizen groups opposed Pizarchik’s confirmation to the OSMRE job, but that he recently promised to take steps to reduce the impacts of mining on the environment and on coalfield communities. See previous posts here, here and here.

(more…)

Breaking news: EPA delays decision on coal ash rules

Thursday, December 17, 2009

apcoalash.jpg

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency just announced it was delaying the release of its proposed rules on coal ash handling and disposal for an unspecified “short period.”

lisaonbrown.jpgEPA Administrator Lisa Jackson had promised to issue the rule — prompted in large part by the coal-ash disaster a year ago in East Tennessee (See photo above) — by the end of 2009.

Here’s the statement from EPA’s press office:

EPA’s pending decision on regulating coal ash waste from power plants, expected this month, will be delayed for a short period due to the complexity of the analysis the agency is currently finishing.

As part of her commitment to ensuring the protection of public health and the environment regarding coal ash, EPA Administrator Lisa P. Jackson had set a deadline to complete the regulatory decision before the close of this year.  However, the agency is still actively clarifying and refining parts of the proposal.

Coal ash is a by-product of the combustion of coal at power plants, which is collected and later disposed of on land. Coal ash was brought prominently to national attention in 2008 when an impoundment holding disposed ash waste generated by the Tennessee Valley Authority broke open, creating a massive spill in Kingston, TN, that covered millions of cubic yards of land and river and is regarded as one of the worst environmental disasters of its kind in history.  Shortly afterwards, EPA began overseeing the cleanup, as well as investigating the structural integrity of impoundments where ash waste is stored.

Administrator Jackson has been committed since the beginning of her Administration to complete these efforts, and expects to issue a proposed rule in the near future.

 

OSMRE backs WVDEP reading of ‘buffer zone’ rule

Thursday, December 17, 2009

dumping.jpg

The U.S. Office of Surface Mining Reclamation and Enforcement has issued a letter that strongly backs the West Virginia Department of Environmental Protection’s currently regulatory practices regarding mountaintop removal mining.

I’ve posted a copy of the letter here.  In it, the Obama administration’s Interior Department rejects a request by West Virginia citizen groups that OSMRE take over enforcement of the stream “buffer zone” rule from WVDEP.

The Appalachian Center for the Economy and the Environment filed the takeover petition with OSMRE back in August, alleging that WVDEP’s interpretation of the buffer zone rule — exempting valley fills from stream protections –  “renders the regulation meaningless.”

In a letter to Joe Lovett of the Appalachian Center, OSMRE regional director Thomas D. Shope explained:

The state program applies the SBZ rule in a manner that allows the placement of excess spoil fills, refuse piles, slurry impoundments, and sedimentation ponds in intermittent and perennial streams. However … the state uses procedures and processes to reduce, minimize and in some cases eliminate the placement of fill in streams in order to reduce the environmental impacts.

(more…)

Rahall releases letter on Fola Coal permit

Thursday, December 17, 2009

rahall_photo.jpgU.S. Rep. Nick J. Rahall’s office has released this letter that the West Virginia Democrat sent to the Army Corps of Engineers regarding the potential layoffs of 500 CONSOL Energy miners in Clay County, W.Va.:

 On November 24, 2009, Judge Robert C. Chambers of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of West Virginia ordered that permits for Consol Energy’s Fola and Little Eagle operations be remanded to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers for further action.  However, noting that substantial mining operations were ongoing, Judge Chambers also stayed his own decision for 60 days to allow time for the parties to appeal or to seek other relief.  

(more…)

Two more coal mining deaths: “Just a freak accident”??

Thursday, December 17, 2009

I cringed when I read this story on WSAZ’s Web site about the death of coal miner Phillip Newton, a 35-year-old, crushed in a roof fall Wednesday night at Sapphire Coal Co.’s Sandlick II Mine in Letcher County, Ky.

It was this quote that did it:

“It’s just a freak accident, just one of those things, you know, something sad happening here around Christmas to the family.” said Letcher County coroner Wallace Bolling.

First, how does this coroner know it was a “freak accident”? The story doesn’t say.

A lot of folks like to talk about these mining deaths as either “freak accidents” or — even worse — as the fault of a miner who puts himself in an unsafe place.

The facts just don’t back up such arguments. In my series, Beyond Sago: Coal Mine Safety in America, I found that 9 out of 10 times, when coal miners die on the job, it’s because the operator they work for violated safety regulations.

(more…)

New report: Mining support jobs facing huge decline

Thursday, December 17, 2009

coalminers.jpg

Coal miners exit the elevator leaving the North River No. 1 Mine some 700 feet underground after finishing their shift, Jan. 5, 2006 in Berry, Ala. Photo by AP.

A new report from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics paints a grim picture for the mining industry.

The report lists “Support activities for mining” among the 10 industries expected to have the largest employment declines over the next decade.  Employment in that sector (see here for definition, as it’s not just coal mining support activities) is projected to decline by nearly a quarter, from 328,000 to 252,000, by 2018.

(more…)