“The Beers to You Tasting Panel” was called together on short notice to once again crank-out a quick review of two beers sent to us by the good folks at Magic Hat Brewing Company. M-H usually brew a special beer each season along with a second beer they appropriately call their “Odd Notion” which is usually a one-beer freak show of sorts and this season’s Odd Notion didn’t break the cycle.
This time we only had three beer-geeks empaneled for this winter tasting. The sometimes curmudgeonly Charles Bockway, the usually grumpy Rob Absten and me, the guy that talks too much for his own good. I threw this panel together in about two hours time and it just shows how desperate some of us are for an excuse to drink beer.
The first beer was called “Howl- Black-As-Night Winter lager. A quick beer-snob analysis of the beer and its specs confirm that this beer is modeled after the classic German Schwarzbier style, a black lager hailing from the Franconian region of Bavaria. The beer poured an opaque black with a decent off-white head. Feedback on the beer’s aroma was mixed, with Charles insisting on a vegetal smell whereas I was leaning more towards a flabby red wine. Rob thought it smelled a little like a chemical aroma or maybe tannins. The aroma became a little better after the beer warmed a bit, with all of us agreeing on a root-vegetable aroma. The taste however, was thoroughly good and agreeable to all. The beer features an intense raisiny and toasted flavor thanks to the use of modern de-bittered malts hailing from the very region of Schwarzbier. The beer starts out fairly malty, never sweet and then finishes clean and dry. I am going to buy more of this beer and the others agreed to drink it if I bought it…
Magic Hat regularly releases what it calls its Odd Notion. This is always an odd sort of beer that lives up to its name and is only available in the “Feast of Fools 12-pack”. The Winter 09, odd notion is an American Sour Ale. The panel was looking forward to this beer as we all like a good sour beer once in a while. I did say “good” sour beer… This beer is not one of those and we all agree on that point. The beer’s aroma is reminiscent of draft Bass Ale and is very similar in color. The beer seems to be a basic English ale but with some lactic acid sourness (probably from acidulated malt). If anyone out there knows really good sour beers like Rodenbach, for instance they will attest to the nutty flavors and the complex acidity in the beer which is a result of a complex yeast and bacterial fermentation. Our Odd Notion “American Sour Ale” was very one-dimensional and I believe a potential turn-off to a neophyte beer drinker that might otherwise enjoy a well made sour beer. Craft beer already faces enough challenges, but imagine having to show up to the game with the “Sour Beer” label, even a world-class sour beer faces the challenge of getting someone to take that first sip. I am afraid it would be the last sip if this were their sour beer debut.




Subscribe to Beers To You